The Ryanair in Winter
Dear Sir,
The publicity given to Ryanair’s recent comments, through the MDB, on the reduction of winter landing charges here at Palma airport has brought a number of comments from both journalists and readers regarding the thorny subject of winter flights. Ryanair, keen as any other airline, to reduce its operating costs, did not say that it would provide more flights if these charges were to be reduced. The conference was essentially a PR exercise, and a very effective one too if judged by the exposure given the following day and by Frank Leaver’s article of today, Wednesday 21 January.
The conference was aimed, I imagine, at re establishing the airline’s credibility after the past, near, disasters created by the CEO Michael O’Leary; I blush when I recall many of his condescending references to Ryanair’s customers and air travellers in general. After two profit warnings, in as many months, at the end of 2013, Michael O’Leary adopted a low profile and since then Ryanair has focused on building a more acceptable image and regaining its position with the Spanish Aviation Authority; well done David O’Brien, If there are two Blarney Stones then David kissed the right one.
David O’Brien merely said that reducing landing charges would make it easier for airlines to provide more flights. It is all about minimising costs while continuing to maximise income by charging the highest fares acceptable to the market at a particular time. A parallel situation would be if a small town offered Waitrose a rent free large store and free car park, no doubt they would be happy to open a supermarket on that site but still market their products at the same price as their other stores.
Thanks to Ryanair, the subject of winter flights is again to the forefront. It would seem, from all the comments appearing in the MDB that people are more concerned with the difficulties of, and the extra time involved with, having to take an extra flight to Barcelona or an extra flight or rail journey from one of the only four UK winter destinations. In all the letters and articles I have read in the MDB, I cannot recall anyone saying that winter flights are too expensive; and some, over the Christmas period, are expensive.
If this is indeed the case then there is no commercial justification for the airlines not to provide a winter service to all, or most, of the normal UK summer destinations, albeit at a reduced frequency depending on demand. In fact this would amount to some thirteen airports in addition to the four already served in winter. To provide one flight per week to each destination would require just one aircraft making two returns flights per day, which is certainly not over utilisation of the available resources.
Obviously, should demand require more seats to be available, then two or more return flights would be required to some or all of the destinations thus requiring two or even more aircraft.
How much will all this cost and how much will be saved in time and effort. Considering only journeys from Palma to Newcastle and Glasgow, other destinations will by around the same, the cost of making a two flight trip (via Barcelona or a present UK airport) during mid week, including the extra cost for baggage on the second flight, is about £115 to Newcastle and £80 to Glasgow.
These costs can be considerably more depending on the time of the day and the day of the week. In terms of time, and depending on the frequency of flights in and out of the connecting airport or train times, this can be anything from eight hours to fourteen hour on a good day.
Direct winter flights from Palma to the UK, and considering that the aircraft will be only some 65% full rather than the 85% which airlines use to set average fares, the cost should work out at around £94 for a single journey with a time, from Palma to the selected destination, of about two hours thirty minutes. Of course, should the passenger load creep up to 85% the fare could be reduced to about £72.
Another option, not forgetting our friends in Minorca and Ibiza, is to route some flights through one or other of these airports. Unfortunately the cost of adding an extra sector would require thirty six passengers to join the flight at either Minorca or Ibiza and the time would be increased by one hour and fifteen minutes making the whole journey time to the UK in the region of three hours and forty five minutes. However, through passengers would stay on board the aircraft and their hold luggage would remain in the aircraft hold.
Without getting too carried away, another possibility is to offer a ‘super’ class for up to say thirty six passengers. These passengers would occupy two abreast seating, normally used for fifty four economy passengers as three abreast, but as the aircraft, even at 85% full, will have twenty seven spare seats, no revenue will be lost. This super class would be easily converted back to six abreast seating when required. The cost of this ‘super’ class could be provided for around £135 and would include:
Extra leg room – 31 inches rather than 29 inches
Two abreast seating – aisle and window with a table in between
Seat selection
Normal cabin bag plus a smaller bag (computer, brief case or shoulder bag)
Dedicated bag drop at check-in – no waiting so later arrival at airport
Last to board and first off with hold luggage first on baggage reclaim carousel
Normal charge for hold baggage but 25 kgs allowance rather than usual 20 kgs
Free snack plus unlimited coffee or tea
Dedicated cabin crew member
Missed flight insurance – if at the airport within four hours of departure
The cost of those extras which can be added to a normal economy seat booked on other airlines, amounts to about £55. For the £135 super class fare, all the foregoing can be enjoyed plus extra luggage weight, extra cabin bag, two abreast seating, luggage first at baggage reclaim and a dedicated cabin crew member.
The money generated from this super class could reduce the economy fare by £1 to £10 depending on the number of seats sold in super class.
Which airline will offer such a super class? Probably none but perhaps a new Balearic airline, jointly owned by the government and the large hotel groups or whosoever, can provide the answer. But that is another story.
The above suggestions have been explained in, what I hope are, simple terms. The whole subject is very complicated and involved, but I feel that enough has been given to show the possibilities available and perhaps the way ahead.

Tom Leeming

Dear Sir,
I am afraid I must disagree with the editor’s opinion about manifestos. As far as I am concerned they are not worth the paper, or computer screen, they are written on.
The only truthful manifesto I have ever read was Churchill’s Blood, Toil, Tears and Sweat one. I would like to think that most people who live in democracies were able to make their minds up without reading a piece of paper full of half truths plucked out of thin air. Anyway, who can guarantee that any idea published in a manifesto will be brought to fruition? Certainly not the people who wrote them. Only six months ago Mr Salmond and Ms Sturgeon were claiming that with North Sea oil income, Scotland would be the land of milk and honey. Not at the current price it won’t be.
Yours sincerely,
Simon Tow

Dear Sir,
What is Mr Moore’s seeming obsession with attracting a never ending stream of people, of whatever type, to the shores of Majorca come winter, autumn, spring.. oh and summer? He bangs on and on about it, ad nauseam, as if the residents of this island (indigenous or otherwise) want nothing more than to be inundated by even more tourists 365 days a year. The measure of something’s quality - as in that of “life”, is not always determined by some sort of endless need to reassure oneself of one’s own popularity. Mr Moore would be well advised to recognise this, along with the fact that this island already attracts more tourists than almost any place of its size on the planet. Please let us enjoy the cyclical nature of this wonderful island without being repeatedly told how much better it could be if Ryanair were flying  a multitude of uninterrupted flights into Palma airport every day of the year.
Duke Higgs

Winter flights
Dear Sir
In response to Tom Leemings letter ,Friday 23 January. I apreciate his knowledge and experience as a retired Pilot. His ideas and concepts of seating, and costing for travel, are interesting. However, most of the Winter travellers are looking for the best price. They are mostly retired apartment owners, Spanish shoppers to London, returning students from Christmas, New Year and the Three Kings. I travelled this month to and from Stansted, because Ryanair discounted their fares by 25%. Total return fare £45. Both Flights were full of the afore mentioned passengers. Unless there were a few " Tourists " on the Flights. Where did they stay?. Was it in Palma, where there are Hotels OPEN!. Elsewhere the Urbanisations are closed. I have made my observations in the past, concerning Winter attractions etc. But nothing has been done.
Returning to Flights, those who live in Scotland etc., may wish to fly to Heathrow, and then on Scheduled Flights to and from Mallorca. I know those costs may be higher, but better than the costs suggested by Mr. Leeming. In fact any connecting Flight to and from Heathrow, has to be a much better way of travelling in UK during the Winter weather.
If there is no demand, the Hotels will close. If there is no demand, the Low Cost Carriers will not put on Flights. If there are no Attractions, to offset the variable Winter weather, there will be no demand. The Bars and Restaurants will close. There will be no employment. Mallorca is again generally CLOSED.
Yours sincerely
Mr. F.S.Jessop
Sa Coma ( CLOSED )


Dear Sir
After 30 years of travelling to Mallorca for our family holidays i think we are going to have to start looking towards booking somewhere else as looking at flights in high season Mallorca is possibly charging too much for landing fees and this is reflecting on ticket prices on the airlines.Maybe its time you realised tourists will not stand for the high prices and choose to go elsewhere.

Karen King


The content of comment is the opinion of users and netizens and not of

Comments contrary to laws, which are libellous, illegal or harmful to others are not permitted'); - reserves the right to remove any inappropriate comments.


Please remember that you are responsible for everything that you write and that data which are legally required can be made available to the relevant public authorities and courts; these data being name, email, IP of your computer as well as information accessible through the systems.

* Mandatory fields

Currently there are no comments.