The carnival parade in Palma always has its fair share of humour. One of the floats was taking aim at the need to speak Catalan in the health service. “We want the best doctors, not linguists,” “healthcare is the priority not language,” was their war cry. Now, obviously they have a point and it appears that the Balearic government has dropped the requirement of speaking Catalan as a necessity to work in the health service. But I was interested to see and hear that the anti-language float drew a mixed reception from the crowd. Catalan is a big issue in Majorca and as a previous Balearic government saw to their cost with their three language learning system in local schools, it can cost you dearly. I would say that the island is effectively split over Catalan. People who have moved from the mainland are obviously some of the biggest critics while the “home grown” population are some of its biggest supporters. Now, yes it is very important that we have the best doctors but at the same time some people prefer to be spoken to in their own language. I would say that the best way forward is to just sit on the fence. Catalan shouldn´t be a requisite to work in the health service staff but at the same time people who do speak it will have a greater edge when applying for a job. It is easy to criticise Catalan and most of the arguments made against it are very valid. But at the end of the day it does form part of the heritage of this island and many will defend it to the end.


The content of comment is the opinion of users and netizens and not of

Comments contrary to laws, which are libellous, illegal or harmful to others are not permitted'); - reserves the right to remove any inappropriate comments.


Please remember that you are responsible for everything that you write and that data which are legally required can be made available to the relevant public authorities and courts; these data being name, email, IP of your computer as well as information accessible through the systems.

* Mandatory fields

Will / Hace over 2 years

Its the young who will suffer by taking away their employment opportunities. It’s a bit like UK leaving the EU, if you only want to stick to a small club you miss out on the wider, grater and more lucrative opportunities. The wider the choice the greater the opportunities.


osn / Hace over 2 years

The unpopularity of the three language system in the schools a few years ago was mainly about the weight given to English. The central argument was that teaching non language subjects in English was problematic in that there weren't enough teachers who could speak English while being a specialist in the subject being taught and text books for the national curriculum were not available in English.


Sarah / Hace over 2 years

Yes sadly Mallorca has damaged the career opportunities of a generation of young adults and now the second generation with their pro Catalan attitude in schools. Extremely sad for the youngsters. Thankfully the Crisis has helped as many left the shores of Mallorca to seek work opportunities in the UK and Germany.


S. / Hace over 2 years

May I thank ALL the Doctors in Mallorca who have been kind enough to speak English, although I have tried to speak The Spanish Language over and over again !.